Web design is not graphic design!
October 11th, 2006
Miriam & Liam got me thinking when they made this point:
“It’s a sad fact of life that a major percentage of web designers out there continue to confuse graphic design skill with web design know-how. Kids fresh out of design school and even more experienced designers who really should know better continue to produce splash/flash/image heavy web pages that read as utter blanks to the search engine spiders.”
The issue of web versus graphic design moves beyond SEO. Most websites are not very usable. Most website viewers have to guess where to go, what to do, or what to expect when they “click here”. Beyond that, graphic-intensive web sites exclude two important segments of the market: dial-up users and the visually impaired.
Dial-up users require more time to load pages because their connection is slower than the broadband most developers have access to. Having lots of graphics or Flash plug-ins (or worse, a whole site designed in Flash) means long load times.
Guess what? Most people don’t wait. Even dial-up users have a threshold for pain and the pain of waiting for an 200K splash page to open is just too much. By time it finishes loading they could have got what they wanted from your competition - and the viewer knows it (how does this experience affect your brand?).
About 8% of internet users have some kind of visual disability. Do you want to pick up 8% of your market that your competitor isn’t reaching? Support the disabled. It isn’t difficult and isn’t that much more expensive but it does require a firm understanding of the W3C guidelines and usability issues that don’t seem to be covered in design class when all the students are trying desperately to “outcool” each other.
By the way, unless you are a design firm “cool” doesn’t sell.
Professional website design is clean, clear and attractive. Professional website design disappears in favor of the message presented. Professional web design enforces your brand without attaching a bad user experience to it.
Web design does use a lot of the principles of graphic design. Having your “look good” in action requires an understanding of composition, color use, typography and more. But web design takes these principles to a much higher level when the screen asks the viewer to do something no piece of paper has ever managed to do.
Interact.
Graphic designers must understand graphic design tools and have a good working knowledge of how the ink will hit the paper. Web designers have to have a good working knowledge of code, browser issues, scripting, resizing issues, speaking multiple languages, plug-ins, bandwidth, presentation, sales and even graphic design!
The best web sites are not fliers or brochures. They engage the viewer. They elicit a response. And they provide a memorable journey that somehow improved the viewer’s life.
Even at 56K.



